Police called to a borough council meeting about feral cats in America

-

NEWS AND COMMENT-NEW BERLIN, USA: This is a nice story which dramatically highlights how council meetings about feeding feral cats and about TNR programs regarding feral cats can become heated. In this instance arguments developed to the point where the borough council secretary felt it necessary to call the sheriff. Two officers arrived to keep the peace. The report is that they had to supervise the meeting.

This is not directly about Maine Coon cats. I have to mention that because this site is about Maine Coon cats 🤔. But it is about cats in general. I would like to think that feral cats have equal rights to Maine Coon cats. The former lives in very tough conditions, abandoned and often forgotten except for TNR volunteers. The latter are often cosseted, pampered, loved and well cared for. They both are sentient beings. They can both feel pain and emotions. They are equal. One is far more vulnerable than the other and therefore need our help.

In general terms, this was an argument between the New Berlin Borough Councillors and the citizens of that town who were involved with TNR programs in managing feral cat colonies which also includes feeding them.

Peaceful, quiet and ordered New Berlin, Pennsylvania, USA
Peaceful, quiet and ordered New Berlin, Pennsylvania, USA. This is a church in New Berlin. The place looks very quiet, peaceful and well-managed except for meetings about feeding feral cats!

Some time ago, before this meeting, the mayor had written an ordinance (a local law) about managing feral cats. She now admits that she did a bad job because it is too ambiguous. It needs to be clearer. She wants to fix the problem and amend it. It was written in good faith on the basis that feral cats are between wild cats and domestic cats in her words. The law was written to address the growing population of feral cats.

This ordinance was finalised in April and apparently doesn't allow for animals to run at large in the community. I'm told that it says that any feral or community cat becomes the responsibility of the person or persons who feed them.

And the people who feed the feral cats as part of a TNR program are now being told to stop feeding them by the New Berlin Borough Council. 

It seems that the council is siding with the citizens of the town by saying that feral cats spread disease and are a danger to children. And if you feed feral cats the problem is that you attract more feral cats and indeed wildlife which increases the potential for disease spreading. My comment on that is that you can feed feral cats as part of a TNR program as long as you feed them in a controlled way and don't leave the food down indefinitely. I don't know whether that was discussed; it probably was.

Members of the Cherished Cats Rescue Alliance and other citizens attended the meeting last week to express their disagreement with the council's decision to stop feeding stray cats (I presume this means feral and stray cats). They suggested that a committee should be formed to clarify the current ordinance which as mentioned above is defective. That idea was shouted down.

Ed Pilko, a person involved in TNR, said that anything other than TNR is "cruel, ridiculous and ineffective". He and his wife have neutered 43 cats and adopted three and rehomed many others under their TNR program.

Despite their good work, there have been complaints made to the council about feral cats. These complaints included suggestions that the feeding of feral cats should stop and that they should be starved. Clearly, a cruel suggestion.

The conversation between the citizens attending the meeting and the councillors became heated almost immediately. In fact, even before the meeting started. Borough Council President Julianne Finkbiner told the attending citizens that only one person was allowed to talk about the feral cat issue. A resident immediately reminded her that she was violating the Pennsylvania Sunshine Act which is a law governing open meetings. The president relented and the meeting then started.

She then said that they will only be allowed to speak for 2 minutes instead of the usual 5. This resulted in more arguments. Finkbiner then shouted at the citizens. She said "This council has stuff to do and we have jobs. This is annoying. Do you know why I do this job? Because no one else will do it."

At that point the borough secretary, Rebecca A Witmer decided to call the sheriff department to try and restore some order to the meeting.

Comment: as mentioned council meetings about TNR get heated. This isn't the first time. There are really two points of view: either you favour a humane approach to feral cats and operate TNR which includes feeding the cats; or you favour the residents and take a more hard-line stance against feral cats which variously includes trapping and killing them or as mentioned starving them and stopping feeding them.

Councillors rarely ban TNR because TNR is a very useful way to deal with feral cats. It is highly positive and if conducted over a long period of time it is effective. People do see real benefits. The problem with it is that you have to feed the cats and a lot of citizens hate that. And of course a lot of people dislike feral cats. Some people hate them. They want to kill them, to eradicate them. But that doesn't work too because anybody who knows about feral cats has heard of the "vacuum effect". You kill some feral cats and new feral cats arrive to take their place. And killing cats that have been put there by irresponsible people is cruel.

These sorts of meetings take place across America all the time. They are indicative of a constant battle between two opposing viewpoints. The meetings are always reactive: how to deal with the presence of feral cats. Sometimes the meetings are better because they are proactive: a discussion about how to stop the creation of feral cats. But those are fraught with difficulty as well because it means a curtailment of human liberties and rights which people also dislike.

My thanks to the lieverthuis.info website and wkok.com.

Location: New Berlin, PA, USA

Comments

  1. Megan Noe24 December 2021 at 15:20

    Ummm...What America are you speaking about because I definitely have been everywhere in my country darn near and these meetings are not happening everywhere about the feral cat population. Actually countys are coming together to make it possible by 2030 that their county is a no kill county. We don't have feral cat problems that results to the need of raining poison hotdogs from the air so you are spreading very misinformed information which can actually be detrimental in retrospect!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Michael Broad LLB, ARPS24 December 2021 at 20:29

      The 'feral cat problem' is discussed quite a lot at council meetings in the USA at county and city level. It is a fact. The meetings can get heated because animal advocates are passionate about animal welfare.

      Delete
  2. Megan Noe24 December 2021 at 15:23

    I'm not saying that this isn't a real situation in this city of course but it's not a rising issue in America just yet and the biggest tool to avoid a deadly inhumane outcome is definitely the catch, snip, release programs!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Michael Broad LLB, ARPS24 December 2021 at 20:27

      Thanks, Megan, for sharing your thoughts. I love TNR. The anti-cat brigade don't like it.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Please share your Maine Coon experiences.

Popular posts from this blog

The extreme Maine Coon face

-
Image
This is an example of extreme breeding. This is a Maine Coon but this cat is an extreme and rare example of this breed. This is not the way they look normally. This face is almost like an aggressive robot with the piercing eyes and the huge muzzle.  Or like a lion's head. The head looks enormous and very heavy. It looks unreal. But it also looks very impressive.  And purchasers like impressive-looking domestic cats. But this not the face of a Maine Coon that wins cat show competitions as it does not fit the breed standard as accurately as the more moderate winners (see below).  In fact, the CFA standard is clear in that the cat should have a balanced appearance although this cat was not bred under the CFA breed standard as I understand it (see below).  Click here for more on the kind of MC which wins at shows . Maine Coon selectively breed to have an extreme face. Image in the public domain. And the Maine Coon is meant to be a large cat, the largest domestic cat b...
Read more

No part of a Maine Coon cat should be exaggerated

-
Image
It is interesting to read that the premier cat association, the CFA (Cat Fanciers' Association) - the cat association which really dictates (with TICA) how Maine Coons should look - makes it clear that no part of the cat should be exaggerated, and the cat should be "well-proportioned and balanced".  In other words, any form of extreme appearance such as a particularly heavy muzzle or particularly large ears with extra-long lynx tips are not going to be seen as advantageous in terms of winning cat shows or in terms of having an ideal appearance. As soon as I read that no part of a Maine Coon should be exaggerated, I immediately thought of the extremely large, extreme-bred Maine Coon cats that often come from Russia. These cats have very heavy muzzles.  Lion-faced Maine Coon with exaggerated features. Image in public domain now. In fact, their heads look like the heads of lions. I get the impression that breeders have selectively bred their cats over years to look like male...
Read more

Eerie picture of a Maine Coon sitting like a human on a chest of drawers

-
Image
This is a slightly scary picture according to those who've seen it. One social media user said it was the devil and "If I walked into a room and saw that, I would assume some shit is about to go down". There is a ghostly stillness and sinister feeling about the image. 'Eerie' is a better description. This attractive cat appears to be completely at ease and comfortable sitting on top of a chest of bedroom drawers. The lighting from below (deliberate?) enhances the eerie effect. It seems possible that this is a photo-edited image but if so, it has been done with great skill. However, I don't think this is Photoshopped. Rethink: to be honest, the more I look at the picture, the more I feel that this is a photo-edited image. It is just too unnatural to be real. Although some domestic cats get themselves into some very strange positions. Maine Coon calmly sitting just like a human on a chest of drawers. Picture source unclear. Image deemed to be in the public d...
Read more

Black smoke Maine Coon Richie with a black face and diamond eyes

-
Image
Black smoke Maine Coon Richie with a black face and diamond eyes. Photo: Instagram. OMG, this is a Maine Coon with an amazing face. His full name is "Richie du Mont d’Even". I think he has a black smoke coat which has created this black face with the assistance of other genes (polygenetic influence?) and ears with piercing, diamond eyes. This is a very special cat. Richie looked very interesting but relatively plain as a kitten. Image: Instagram. His paws are balls of fluff. He has a mane that goes over his head like a halo. He's angelic and other-worldly. The lynx tips on the end of his ears are smoky grey which makes them stand out. They are a bit like the opposite to the black lynx tips of the wild caracal.  He lives in France with his human: Adriana Piraino. He was born on 7th November 2020. He is still very young. They say Maine Coons reach adulthood at around the age of 4. He is going to be enormous as well. Richie with Adriana. Photo: Instagram Richie was bred b...
Read more

Comparison of a black smoke Maine Coon at 6 weeks and 6-years-of-age

-
Image
This is a cross-post as the image is so damned good. It is amazing because the cat is amazing. To put the same cat at different stages of their life in the same photograph is a nice idea especially with this Maine Coon (MC) who has an amazingly heavy face. It is so mightily masculine to be almost unbelievable. He has a priceless expression on his face too. Very serious compared to the innocence of his face when he was 6 weeks old. He looks a bit coy when 6 weeks old and a slightly grumpy middle-aged man when 6 years old. Comparison of a black smoke Maine Coon at 6-weeks and 6-years-of-age. Image in pubic domain. No doubt he is huge too. You get a clear sense of that in the image. There is a serious and less impressive side to this image. It's the backstory that people don't really want to read about and discuss or in fact do anything about: heart ( HCM ) and joint disease. The bigger and heavier the MCs are the more predisposed to heart disease they are. Here is the posts on...
Read more

Parisian Maine Coon 'crème et blanc'

-
Image
PARIS: This is a handsome Parisian Maine Coon described by his human caretaker as: "My little lynx Jiyuu of Roswell Maine Coon crème et blanc 19 mois mâle". The translation is: his name is Jiyuu of Roswell. His coat is cream and white. He is 19 months old. Oh, and his is damned handsome. The photo is by his guardian: Lunatique- girl . Cream and white Maine Coon living in Paris, France. Photo: Lunatique Girl. It is a really nice Maine Coon photo of a really nice Maine Coon with an interesting coat colour. I think the main colour is more milk chocolate, cappuccino or fawn! Anyway, super-looking cat. Is he a cream tabby? I think so.
Read more

Maine Coon size versus dog size?

-
Image
People want to know how the size of the Maine Coon compares to the size of a dog. You probably realise that it is impossible to answer this question because dog size varies enormously. This is due to selective breeding over about 20 years or more. And, it has to be said, the size of the Maine Coon also varies considerably.  A Beagle versus a large Maine Coon comparing size. Image: MikeB based on images in the public domain. Here is another image comparing a Beagle and a standard Maine Coon from a YouTube video: Standard Maine Coon versus a Beagle comparing size. Screenshot. Small-to-medium-sized dog compared to a Maine Coon size. Image in public domain. This looks like a small Maine Coon. And here is a Golden Retriever and Maine Coon playing. This dog breed is quite large: People get the impression that all Maine Coons are always huge but they are not. Maine Coons can be a little larger than standard domestic cats (small female for instance) but in general they are considerably ...
Read more

2 top Russian Maine Coon cat breeders which ship internationally

-
Image
I am writing this from the West; specifically, near London, UK. There will be quite a few people living in the West who'd like to adopt a Maine Coon cat and they would like to adopt one from a Russian breeder because they do have a certain style.  I sense, although I don't have hard evidence to support this feeling, that the top Russian breeders of Maine Coon cats might be superior to breeders from other countries.  I am putting aside Putin's invasion of Ukraine when writing this article. Some people might object to dealing in anyway with a Russian business on account of that barbaric and illegal invasion. We should remember that Russia has quite a strong cat fancy. They like their cats and they love their purebred cats particularly the Maine Coon. It is in fact a cat breed which is quite naturally suited to the Russian way of life and climate. There's lots of space in Russia with a relatively low population and therefore there are going to be houses with large grounds ...
Read more

5 Maine Coon transformations from kitten to adult (video)

-
Image
Maine Coon kitten and his adult self. Photo: Robert Silka. This is a series of photographs by the very famous Maine Coon photographer: robert_sijka. I think he presents his photographs too dark as there is not enough information in the photographs for my liking but he takes great photographs of great Maine Coon cats. In this series he photographs a kitten and their adult version. Each individual cat is a wonderful example of the Maine Coon breed. I can count five examples. In my experience, these Google Blogger videos only work if you click the centre play button and then, immediately afterwards, the play button bottom-left! It sounds bad but the short video is worth watching.
Read more

Difference between Maine Coon and domestic long hair

-
Image
The difference between a Maine Coon cat and a domestic longhaired cat comes down to the fact that the former has been artificially bred (selective breeding) whereas the latter has usually procreated according to natural selection. Natural selection is random breeding and therefore the domestic longhair is a random-bred cat whereas, selective breeding produces a purebred, pedigree cat registered with a cat association.  Difference between Maine Coon and domestic long hair. Infographic by MikeB. And because each individual Maine Coon cat is registered with a cat association, if they are in genuine Maine Coon, their appearance should comply with the association's breed standard . The breed standard tells breeders what their Maine Coon cats should look like in order that they can win cat show competitions if they want to enter their cat into these competitions. And so, as the appearance of Maine Coon cats is moulded to the guidance of a breed standard (see a section below from the...
Read more